Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P vs GivEnergy Giv-Bat 9.5 Gen 3

On their best tariffs, the two save about the same: £800 and £796 a year.

Side by side

Detail Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P GivEnergy Giv-Bat 9.5 Gen 3
Usable capacity9.6 kWh9.5 kWh
Charge / discharge5 / 5 kW3.6 / 3.6 kW
Round-trip efficiency90%90%
Guide price£2,442 per unit (checked Nov 2026)£3,096 per unit (checked Nov 2026)
Best tariffOctopus Intelligent Octopus Go 12M Fixed - EV Saver November 2026 v1Octopus Intelligent Octopus Go 12M Fixed - EV Saver November 2026 v1
Saving a year£800£796
Payback3.1 years4.0 years

In London at 4,000 kWh a year, the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P saves more on 74 of 82 tariffs and the GivEnergy Giv-Bat 9.5 Gen 3 on none (8 about the same).

Saving a year on each tariff

Tariff Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P GivEnergy Giv-Bat 9.5 Gen 3 Difference
Octopus Intelligent Octopus Go 12M Fixed - EV Saver November 2026 v1
Economy 7
£800 £796 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Intelligent Octopus Go 12M Fixed November 2026 v1
Economy 7
£773 £769 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Intelligent Octopus Go
Economy 7
£758 £754 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Point Plug & Power 24m v6 HH
Time-of-use
£734 £730 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Power 18m v5 HH
Time-of-use
£734 £730 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Go Electric 18m v5 HH
Time-of-use
£721 £718 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Power 12m v3 HH
Time-of-use
£721 £717 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Go Electric 12m v3 HH
Time-of-use
£708 £705 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Go 12M Fixed October 2026 v2
Time-of-use
£703 £699 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Point Plug & Power 24m v5 HH
Time-of-use
£668 £665 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Power 18m v4 HH
Time-of-use
£668 £665 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.9
Time-of-use
£667 £663 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V8.0
Time-of-use
£667 £663 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.8
Time-of-use
£660 £656 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Point Plug & Power 24m v4 HH
Time-of-use
£643 £640 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Pod Power 18m v3 HH
Time-of-use
£643 £640 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V37
Time-of-use
£633 £630 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart (Non Connected) V8.0
Time-of-use
£633 £630 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V37
Time-of-use
£633 £630 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Go Electric 18m v3 HH
Time-of-use
£631 £628 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V36
Time-of-use
£626 £623 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V36
Time-of-use
£626 £623 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Go
Time-of-use
£607 £604 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.4
Time-of-use
£599 £596 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.7
Time-of-use
£597 £594 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V35
Time-of-use
£586 £583 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V35
Time-of-use
£586 £583 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.3
Time-of-use
£580 £577 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V31
Time-of-use
£566 £563 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Intelligent Octopus Go
Economy 7
£565 £562 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.6
Time-of-use
£559 £556 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V34
Time-of-use
£549 £546 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V34
Time-of-use
£549 £546 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.5
Time-of-use
£538 £535 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V33
Time-of-use
£528 £525 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V33
Time-of-use
£528 £525 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Smart V7.1
Time-of-use
£526 £523 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V30
Time-of-use
£525 £523 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Drive Fixed V29
Time-of-use
£511 £509 £3 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Sainsburys EV V24
Time-of-use
£444 £442 £2 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Snug Octopus
Time-of-use
£426 £423 £2 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
ScottishPower Heat Pump Saver Oct 2027 v2
Time-of-use
£409 £407 £2 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Good Energy Heat Pump Fixed 12m Oct26
Time-of-use
£398 £396 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
100Green Tide Lifestyle
Time-of-use
£385 £362 £22 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Cosy Octopus 12M Fixed October 2026 v2
Time-of-use
£355 £355 about the same
Octopus Cosy Octopus Variable
Time-of-use
£293 £292 about the same
British Gas Heat Power Oct27 v1
Time-of-use
£289 £288 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Flux Import
Time-of-use
£253 £252 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V51
Time-of-use
£248 £247 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V14
Time-of-use
£248 £247 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V19
Time-of-use
£247 £246 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V12
Time-of-use
£241 £240 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V13
Time-of-use
£240 £239 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V50
Time-of-use
£238 £237 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V55
Time-of-use
£234 £233 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Octopus Agile Octopus October 2024 v1
Half-hourly dynamic
£233 £228 £4 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V20
Time-of-use
£230 £230 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V15
Time-of-use
£228 £227 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V17
Time-of-use
£224 £223 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V10
Time-of-use
£220 £219 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V16
Time-of-use
£218 £217 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V8
Time-of-use
£202 £201 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V11
Time-of-use
£198 £197 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Freephase Static 24m v9 HH
Time-of-use
£195 £195 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V52
Time-of-use
£195 £194 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V47
Time-of-use
£194 £193 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V48
Time-of-use
£194 £193 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V44
Time-of-use
£193 £192 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V53
Time-of-use
£192 £192 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
EDF Heat Pump Tracker 36m
Time-of-use
£192 £191 about the same
EDF Freephase Static 24m v11_HH
Time-of-use
£187 £186 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V49
Time-of-use
£182 £181 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V45
Time-of-use
£175 £175 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V7
Time-of-use
£175 £174 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V54
Time-of-use
£169 £168 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V3
Time-of-use
£163 £162 £1 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V46
Time-of-use
£144 £144 about the same
EDF FreePhase Dynamic 12m v2
Half-hourly dynamic
£139 £136 £2 more with the Alpha ESS SMILE-G3-BAT-10.1P
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V9
Time-of-use
£133 £133 about the same
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 12m V42
Time-of-use
£130 £130 about the same
Eon Next Next Smart Saver Fixed 24m V6
Time-of-use
£119 £118 about the same
Octopus Intelligent Octopus Flux Import
Time-of-use
£7 £7 about the same

How these figures are worked out

  • One real household's half-hourly smart meter readings from 18 November 2025 to 17 November 2026, scaled so the year adds up to 4,000 kWh (Ofgem typical medium (multi-rate)). The daily pattern of use stays real; only the amounts change.
  • Prices for London, including the standing charge. Only tariffs open to new customers with more than one price a day are shown.
  • The battery starts empty, charges from the grid at the cheapest times and powers the home at the dearest, within its usable capacity, charge and discharge power and round-trip efficiency. It never sells to the grid. Solar panels are not included.
  • It plans with perfect knowledge of the day ahead, so the savings are a best case. "With 20% moved" also moves a fifth of each day's use to the cheapest times.
  • Payback is the battery's price divided by its yearly saving, allowing for the battery slowly losing capacity. Prices are guides: check with the installer.

← All batteries